Person completing a phishing awareness quiz on a laptop.

Multiple Choice Is Boring: 5 Better Ways to Measure Learning

If you’ve ever built learning experiences and training modules, you’ve probably ended it with ten multiple choice questions because that’s what everybody does.

Question 1. Check.

Question 2. Check.

Question 10. Congratulations, you’ve clicked enough buttons to prove you’re a cybersecurity expert.

The problem is that multiple choice questions mostly measure whether someone can recognize the right answer. In the real world, employees need to do things, not just spot the correct option from a list.

Here are five assessment techniques that collect useful data while feeling a little less like high school.


1. Scenario-Based Decisions

Instead of asking what policy says, present a realistic situation and ask employees what they would do next.

For example, rather than asking, “What should you do if you receive a suspicious email?” show the email instead and have them choose a course of action in 2-3 sentences.

The data collected isn’t just right or wrong answers. You can see where employees struggle, which decisions are commonly missed, and where additional training may be needed. That’s assessment.


2. Upload Evidence of Completion

Sometimes the best assessment is proving the task was actually completed.

Need employees to perform a safety inspection? Have them upload a photo. Need them to complete a software task? Ask for a screenshot.

Now you’re collecting real-world performance data instead of quiz scores.


3. Short Written Responses

I know. Nobody likes grading essays.

But, asking employees to explain something in only one or two sentences can reveal much more than multiple choice questions.

If someone can explain a process clearly in their own words, they probably understand it. If their answer sounds ineffective, you may have discovered a training gap.

Even AI tools can now help summarize and assess large numbers of responses at once.


4. Demonstrations and Role Play

This works especially well for customer service, leadership, sales, and safety training.

Have employees demonstrate a procedure, record a short video response, or participate in a role-play scenario.

The data becomes much richer because you’re evaluating actual performance instead of theoretical knowledge.


5. Confidence Ratings

After completing training, ask employees to anonymously rate their confidence in performing specific tasks on a scale from one to five, even with a QR Code linked to a Google Form.

The results won’t replace an assessment, but they can identify areas where employees still feel uncomfortable.

If 95% of the workers pass a quiz but only 40% feel confident doing the job, you may have a training problem.


Stop Only Measuring Clicks

Sometimes training departments collect data because it’s easy, not because it’s useful.

A multiple choice quiz certainly has its place. They’re quick, easy to score, and generate nice reports.

But if your goal is to find out whether employees can actually perform a task, consider collecting data from scenarios, demonstrations, uploads, written responses, and confidence ratings.

After all, most jobs don’t come with four possible answers and a “Next Question” button.

Discover more from Matthew Serwedes - Instructional Design & Live Streaming

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading